Currently, Andre Onana stands at the center of Manchester United’s goalkeeper controversy. Indeed, the Cameroonian’s performances have ignited debate among club legends Edwin van der Sar and Peter Schmeichel, who hold distinctly different opinions.
Initially, Manchester United signed Onana in 2023, but now, he faces intense scrutiny after several disappointing displays. Specifically, his errors directly led to both goals in the 2-2 Europa League draw against Lyon. Consequently, Manager Ruben Amorim dropped Onana from the squad for the Newcastle match. Furthermore, Amorim explained that Onana needed to “disconnect” and prepare for future fixtures.
Notably, Peter Schmeichel, one of United’s greatest goalkeepers, expressed serious doubts about Onana’s reliability. “You never feel safe,” remarked Schmeichel, thus highlighting the uncertainty that defenders experience with Onana behind them.
In contrast, Edwin van der Sar offers a more supportive perspective on Onana’s situation. Indeed, the Dutch legend knows Onana’s capabilities well and, therefore, emphasizes his potential growth. “He’s a very strong character, and I think that will help him become one of the very best goalkeepers in the coming years,” Van der Sar stated confidently.
Meanwhile, during the 2024-25 Premier League season, Onana’s numbers tell a mixed story. For instance, he has played 24 matches and recorded 8 clean sheets. Although he has made 58 saves, opponents have nevertheless scored 33 goals against him. As a result, these figures highlight his struggle for consistency.
Additionally, reports indicate several teammates have grown frustrated with Onana. Particularly, they take issue with both his performances and his pre-match comments. Hence, some players now prefer backup goalkeeper Altay Bayindir to take over the starting position.
Undoubtedly, the contrasting views from Van der Sar and Schmeichel reflect the broader debate about Onana’s future. On one hand, some fans and analysts call for patience and development. On the other hand, others demanded immediate changes to stabilize the defense.
Finally, the next few weeks will determine Onana’s future at Old Trafford. Ultimately, can he overcome these challenges and fulfill the potential that supporters like Van der Sar see in him? In conclusion, only time will tell.
-
-
-
-
